There has been a lot of debate over the years about children and television. How much is too much? What is the appropriate length of exposure?
For the majority of my life, I have viewed this debate with a skeptical eye. ”Surely these people have too much time on their hands or else they have something against Disney.”
But after three children I can definitively say this…yup, they are right to worry.
My oldest son is the case in point. The following is a representation of his behavior as it relates to television exposure.
- No TV time = a sweet boy, attentive to his brothers, curious, and very conversational.
- Half-hour of TV = loses attention span, no longer able to self-entertain.
- One hour of TV = hitting one or both brothers becomes vehicle of entertainment.
- Two hours of TV = power of speech limited to, “You never get me anything special,” followed by whatever the toy industry has to offer during the commercial breaks.
- Two hours plus = demonic possession, body levitates, head spins while vomiting.
Now, before you ask the logical question of “What in the world is that kid watching?” let me tell you…it doesn’t matter. From Curious George to the local news, whether Wild Kratts or an informercial, they all turn my son into a raging a-hole.
And keep in mind that this is the child who the teachers love. He is engaged, respectful, and sweet…until you wheel in the TV.
We have taken to calling periods with zero screen time as “detox periods”. This term may sound extreme, but believe me it’s not. Once, after two days without any screen time, I caught him hiding in a closet with my iPad freebasing Sesame Street.
Our other children do not have a similar reaction to the box, but they get to suffer the consequence of their brother’s problem. We never set out to be “those parents”. You know the ones, those who only let
their kids have educational toys and allow them to eat only locally-grown, organic food. Instead, we always took the mindset that our children need have fun while also handling most things in moderation. With TV, our oldest just isn’t there yet.
I have always been a fan of a quote by James Dobson about a parent’s job being to guide kids “from dependence to independence”. We ultimately want him to be able to make these choices on his own. For now, though, we are weekend-only television viewers trying to impart lessons in moderation.
On the plus side we’ll know we are when successful when his damn head stops spinning.
